08.30.2017

Human Traders Retain Edge Over Quants and Algos

 

 

Human traders are seemingly an endangered species in today’s largely electronic, algorithm-driven market, but humans still have an edge over machines in low-volatility markets, according to an eFinancialCareers report.

eFinancialCareers noted that old-school trading pits have been cleared out as electronic trading platforms powered by various types of artificial intelligence, including machine learning and artificial neural networks are in ascendance.

But many quants and algorithmic trading strategies struggle mightily in the absence of market volatility, which means in the current prolonged period of market calm, human traders have an opportunity to prove their worth.

“Some of these algorithms will focus on market-making, trying to capture the difference between the bid and the offer, which are typically categorized as high-frequency trading,” Daniel Gramza, founder and president of Gramza Capital Management and DMG Advisors, told eFinancialCareers. “Sideways or calm markets can be a challenge for the machine-learning trend-following algorithm – primarily because it needs a number of steps to recognize that it may be in a sideways market and how it will trade that environment.”

Human traders can quickly recognize the potential for a sideways move and more easily adjust their trading strategy.

“The trader can assess what is the typical magnitude of a sideways move, how long it typically last, is there a particular time of day, week or month when sideways moves occur and how does it typically break out of the sideways move,” Gramza told eFC. “Although these parameters are simple to assess for the trader, it can be challenging for the machine-learning algorithms.”

“My experience with trading firms around the world is that the human trader still has an edge over the machine-learning algorithms in the calm sideways market environment.”

Related articles

  1. With Eugene Kanevsky, James Redbourn, and Joanna Wong, CLSA

  2. AI/ML on the buy-side trading desk is a long-term program with short- and mid-term deliverables.

  3. Aiden uses the computational power of deep reinforcement learning to improve trading results and insights.

  4. OPINION: Artificial, Yes. Intelligent? Maybe.

    BondDroid’s AI-generated prices are integrated directly into LTX’s pre-trade analytical tools.

  5. Fintech firm has partnered with Jim Toffey, founder of Tradeweb Markets, to create LTX.