Brown To Credit Suisse: Losses Raise Troubling Questions
U.S. Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH), Chairman of the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, pressed some of the world’s biggest banks, including Credit Suisse Securities LLC, Nomura Holding America Inc., Goldman Sachs, and Morgan Stanley for answers about the margin call and market activity connected to Archegos Capital Management.
“I am troubled, but not surprised, by the news reports that Archegos entered into risky derivatives transactions facilitated by major investment banks, resulting in panicked selling of stocks worth tens of billions of dollars and those banks collectively losing nearly $10 billion,” wrote Brown.
Brown continued, “The details and ultimate consequence of Archegos’s failure remain to be seen, but the massive transactions, and losses, raise several questions regarding Credit Suisse’s relationship with Archegos and the treatment of so-called “family offices,” Mr. Hwang’s history, and the transactions that have been mentioned in news reports.”
A copy of the letter to Credit Suisse appears here and below:
Dear Ms. Lalime:
Credit Suisse Securities (USA) LLC
I write concerning your firm’s participation in recent stock market transactions involving Archegos Capital Management (Archegos) and its principal owner Sung Kook (Bill) Hwang.
I am troubled, but not surprised, by the news reports that Archegos entered into risky derivatives transactions facilitated by major investment banks, resulting in panicked selling of stocks worth tens of billions of dollars and those banks collectively losing nearly $10 billion. Similar failures in the past, including Long-Term Capital Management and Amaranth Advisors, demonstrate the hazards to market stability and investor confidence when excessive leverage is combined with careless risk taking.
Based on news reports and discussions with financial regulators, it appears Credit Suisse acted as one of several prime brokers for Archegos and conducted a “margin call” in the last week of March, rapidly liquidating shares of several companies. The details and ultimate consequence of Archegos’s failure remain to be seen, but the massive transactions, and losses, raise several questions regarding Credit Suisse’s relationship with Archegos and the treatment of so-called “family offices,” Mr. Hwang’s history, and the transactions that have been mentioned in news reports.
So that I may better understand the circumstances of the Archegos transactions and Credit Suisse’s involvement, please respond to the following by April 22, 2021. To the extent separate answers or details are necessary to explain activity of different Credit Suisse entities, please describe with specificity for each entity.
- Please outline the know your customer (KYC) review and client onboarding process for family offices, including any consideration given to whether the family office is subject to regulatory registration or reporting;
- Please describe:
- the services offered to family offices through your prime brokerage or similar divisions,
- how family offices are evaluated to determine eligibility for services or products, including the extension of credit,
- if there are services or products that are not offered to family offices that are not subject to regulatory registration or reporting, and
- how collateral, including initial margin and variation margin, is maintained for transactions with those clients;
- With respect to family offices, describe any periodic reviews of client details and KYC information, privileges, and market activity your firm conducts, including their frequency;
- Please explain the client onboarding process, including any supervisor or risk committee approvals, for Archegos, identifying when it became a client, and the consideration of the 2012 agreement to criminal wire fraud by Tiger Asia Management LLC, Mr. Hwang’s prior firm, and his and Tiger Asia Management’s settlement of civil fraud charges related to allegations of insider trading and manipulation that led to a $44 million penalty and an industry bar;
- Identify the broker-dealer, bank, and other entities, directly or indirectly, involved in transactions with Archegos and that participated in the margin call and resulting stock sales;
- Describe any policies or procedures relevant to the entities in item 5 that address providing to U.S. based entities total return swaps or similar transactions referencing publicly traded stocks that provide an economic interest that would be subject to regulatory reporting with the SEC or other regulators if the referenced stocks were directly held;
- To address news reports regarding the Archegos margin call, please explain Credit Suisse’s participation in, or consideration of, any coordination with other banks to sell, or to refrain from selling, stocks related to Archegos transactions;
- As detailed in news reports, Archegos-related margin calls involved the sale of shares of ViacomCBS Inc., which exhibited significant volatility in March, beginning the month at $67, reaching $100, and ending the month at $45. Several of the banks engaged in trading relationships with Archegos participated in an SEC-registered offering of ViacomCBS shares on March 23 at a price of $85. Please discuss whether that offering contributed to the Archegos margin call;
- Given the stunning speed and size of the stock sales leading to Archegos’s failure, please explain any information, market activity, or other factors that you believe caused or contributed to the margin call; and
- Finally, please describe any amendments to policies or documentation that any of the entities identified in item 5 have made, or intend to make, in relation to existing or future transactions or relationships with family offices.
I appreciate your attention to this matter, and thank you for your timely cooperation.
Source: U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs
The bank will accelerate its growth ambitions in the US.
Net profit was more than four times 2020 and the highest since 2011.
Morgan Stanley CEO wants the Fed to raise rates in March.
A fall in overall risk appetite and exiting prime services contributed to the loss.
Firm is investing up to $150m to anchor the team's first strategy.