03.15.2018

Judge Rules Cryptos Are Commodities

03.15.2018

One U.S. judge has declared that cryptocurrencies can be regulated as commodities.

While the Securities and Exchange Commission and Commodities Futures Trading Commission hold hearings and debate just how to properly regulate these new digital assets such as bitcoin, Ripple and others, U.S. District Judge Jack Weinstein in Brooklyn took a stand and made his views known. The federal regulators, as well as Congress, have not passed any policy or laws to policy this new marketplace.

Virtual currencies like bitcoin can be regulated as commodities by the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission. Period.

According to Reuters who reported the story first, said the CFTC had standing to bring a fraud lawsuit against New York resident Patrick McDonnell and his company Coin Drop Markets, allowing the case to go forward.

Weinstein also entered a preliminary injunction barring McDonnell and Coin Drop Markets from engaging in commodity transactions.

McDonnell, who is representing himself, declined to comment on the decision.

The CFTC, which is tasked with regulating commodity, futures and derivatives markets, first determined that virtual currencies, also known as cryptocurrencies, are commodities in 2015.

Weinstein upheld that determination, saying it was supported by the plain meaning of the word “commodity” and that the CFTC had broad leeway to interpret the federal law regulating commodities.

In its lawsuit, announced in January, the CFTC said that since about January 2017, McDonnell and his company fraudulently offered customers virtual currency trading advice.

It's been a month since we had our Women In Finance Awards in New York City at the Plaza! Take a look back tab some moments, and nominate for our upcoming awards in Mexico City and Singapore here: https://www.marketsmedia.com/category/events/

4

Citadel Securities told the SEC that trading tokenized equities should remain under existing market rules, a position that drew responses from various crypto industry groups. @ShannyBasar for @MarketsMedia:

SEC Commissioner Mark Uyeda argued that private assets belong in retirement plans, saying diversified alts can improve risk-adjusted returns and that the answer to optimal exposure “is not zero.” @ShannyBasar reporting for @MarketsMedia:

COO of the Year Award winner! 🏆
Discover how Jennifer Kaiser of Marex earned the 2025 Women in Finance COO of the Year recognition.

Load More

Related articles

  1. Rostin Behnam provided a state of play on the regulator’s business at a recent Bloomberg conference.

  2. Four-paragraph CFTC notice holds firm-level and market-wide implications.

  3. Ambitious regulatory agenda includes risk management, data and technology, and vendor due diligence.

  4. From The Markets

    When Good Intentions Go Awry

    Fonetic COO assesses the unintended consequences of CFTC record retention rules.

  5. A quick take on this week's Senate testimony on the crypto market.