08.16.2017

Massachusetts to Probe Exchange Rebate Pricing

08.16.2017

Maker-taker, taker-maker, or whatever one chooses to call the way exchanges pay brokers to attract order flow is now coming under state regulator review.

According to a report on Reuters, Massachusetts’ top securities regulator said on Tuesday that his office is examining whether brokerages route orders to stock exchanges that pay them additional fees regardless of whether investor clients are getting the best price.

William Galvin, the secretary of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, reportedly has sent inquiry letters to affiliates of several retail and institutional brokers such as Charles Schwab Corp, TD Ameritrade Holdings Corp, Fidelity Investments, E-Trade Financial Corp, Edward Jones and Morgan Stanley, to examine their financial relationships with the exchanges.

At issue is just how the exchanges lure the stock orders from the brokers – with the contention being that broker send orders where their payments or rebates are highest – and not where investors can get the best execution or price.

“If financial rebates or kickbacks create a conflict that results in less than the best deal for the investors, this practice must stop,” Galvin said in a statement announcing the probe.

The action by Massachusetts follows the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s own announcement that it too is planning a proposal to test how lower fees and rebates would affect market behavior. This pilot, SEC Chairman Clayton said in remarks, could decide whether or not maker-taker of other pricing schema should be abolished, regulated or limited.

Galvin in his statement cited an essay by Yale Law School Professor Jonathan Macey and Yale University’s chief investment officer, David Swensen, who argued that brokers choose exchanges at a price disadvantage to investors.

According to Reuters, Fidelity and Schwab are reviewing the matter, representatives said. Edward Jones has not yet received a letter from Galvin’s office.

A recent Markets Media article highlights how @tZERO is resetting its vision - focusing on partnerships, regulated infrastructure, and global scale to make tokenized capital markets a reality.

Under CEO @Alan_Konevsky, the company is leveraging regulatory momentum to enable…

Want to know who calls the shots on trading tech? We partnered with @WeAreAdaptive to interview capital markets professionals globally to uncover key trends and evolving patterns in technology deployment. Reach the report here:

Load More

Related articles

  1. Fair Access Central to Market Review

    This lowers entry barriers for buy-side firms and others not holding a full exchange membership.

  2. Cboe Australia has around 20% of Australia’s equity market turnover, almost $2bn of trades each day. 

  3. J.P. Morgan is hiring senior bankers and traders as other firms cut

    Cboe is focussing on the biggest growth areas, including a go to market plan for event prediction contracts.

  4. 24X National Exchange offers 23-hour weekday trading of U.S. equities.

  5. Institutional trading volume was $236bn, up 22% quarter-on-quarter.

We're Enhancing Your Experience with Smart Technology

We've updated our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy to introduce AI tools that will personalize your content, improve our market analysis, and deliver more relevant insights.These changes take effect on Aug 25, 2025.
Your data remains protected—we're simply using smart technology to serve you better. [Review Full Terms] | [Review Privacy Policy] Please review our updated Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy carefully. By continuing to use our services after Aug 25, 2025, you agree to these

Close the CTA