05.06.2019

Transaction Tax Proposed, Again

05.06.2019

In the attempt to rein in high-frequency trading Democrats in the US House of Representatives and Senate have filed identical bills to establish a transaction tax across a broad range of listed and over-the-counter products that likely will result in throwing out the baby with the bath water.

Sponsors of House Bill 1516 and Senate Bill 647, each entitled The Wall Street Tax Act, seek to enact a 0.1% tax on transactions on trades and margin payments involving “any share of stock in a corporation, any partnership or beneficial ownership interest in a partnership or trust, derivative as well as any note, bond, debenture, or other evidence of indebtedness.”

The authors of the bill only provide exceptions for notes, bonds, debentures, or evidence of indebtedness “that are subject to the rules of, a qualified board or exchange located in the United States, and has a fixed maturity of not more than 100 days.”

Alastair Hawker, QB

“When you delve into the wording of the proposal, it states that the tax is 0.1% of all margin payments paid by the buyer of a derivatives contract,” Alastair Hawker, global head of sales at Quantitative Brokers, told Markets Media. “That is very specific, and also has wide-ranging consequences for different market participants.”

In a recent blog post on the brokerage’s website, Hawker wrote that although the authors of the legislation intended to curb the excesses of high-frequency trading, the financial transaction tax would affect buy-and-hold investors disproportionately.

Using “back of the envelope” calculations, he estimated that an investor who held a 10-Year Treasury Note Future with a notional value of $120,005 and an initial margin of $1,200 for one day without a price change would pay $1.20 for the proposed tax.

If the investor held the same contract and rolled it twice, the initial margin jumps to $3,600 and would pay $111,270 in variation margin payments as well as $115 in financial transaction tax.

“Market makers will not bear the costs,” said Hawker. “They are already on thin margins, so bid-offer spreads will widen. When spreads widen, volatility tends to go up, and it becomes much harder and more expensive to trade.”

He also cited that Sweden experimented with a financial transaction tax on equities, equity options, and fixed income securities in the mid-80s, before lowering and eventually abolishing the tax in 1991.

Although there is a slim chance for the bills to become law in the 116th Congress due to the Democrats holding the House and Republicans controlling the Senate and the White House, the 2020 presidential election is just around the corner, according to Hawker.

“I cannot see anything but a bad situation coming out of a tax like this,” he said. “This is not like a sales tax that you do not like but simply pay it, and it doesn’t change your behavior. This fundamentally will change people’s behaviors, which is their intention. What they probably do not realize is that it ultimately will impact investors like beneficiaries of pension funds through much higher trading costs.”

Markets Media Group was pleased to host the 2025 European Women in Finance Awards last night at Claridge’s in London.
#WomeninFinance #WIF #EuropeanFinance #FinanceCommunity

See the full list of winners here: https://www.marketsmedia.com/2025-european-women-in-finance-awards-the-winners/

3

We are excited to announce the finalists for the 2025 U.S. Women in Finance Awards! Congratulations to all!

Check out the full list here:


#WomeninFinance #WIF #financeindustry

Nominations are NOW OPEN for the 2026 Women in Finance LatAm Awards! Do you know a standout leader, innovator, or rising star? Nominate her today!

Learn more & submit your nomination:

#WomeninFinance #Finance #WIF

HSBC AI Markets harnesses natural language processing to meet market participants’ trading and hedging needs, from pre-trade analysis, to execution, to post-trade. Markets Media caught up with Tom Croft to learn more about the platform.

#AIMarkets

Load More

Related articles

  1. Operator of the Investors Exchange equity venue seeks to port its model to options.

  2. Securities Information Processors move toward 24-hour availability, pending SEC approval.

  3. In 2024 therewere record inflows into digital asset funds globally.

  4. Kevin McPartland of Coalition Greenwich provides a look back at a look ahead.

  5. Three of the four proposals from December 2022 are still open items; will Gensler bat .500?

We're Enhancing Your Experience with Smart Technology

We've updated our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy to introduce AI tools that will personalize your content, improve our market analysis, and deliver more relevant insights.These changes take effect on Aug 25, 2025.
Your data remains protected—we're simply using smart technology to serve you better. [Review Full Terms] | [Review Privacy Policy] Please review our updated Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy carefully. By continuing to use our services after Aug 25, 2025, you agree to these

Close the CTA