02.07.2020

Independent Research Providers Will Lose Most Under MiFID

02.07.2020
Shanny Basar

Independent research providers are expected to be the biggest losers from the unbundling of research in Europe under MiFID II according to a new survey. MiFID II went live in the European Union in 2018 and mandated the separation of research payments and trading commissions, which had traditionally been bundled together.

The majority of respondents, including the independent research providers themselves, predicted that they will be the biggest eventual losers from MiFID II in a survey at London’s Unbundling Uncovered conference in November last year

Losers from MiFID II Source: Singletrack

Singletrack, which provides relationship and research management technology, carried out a survey among the participants at the conference organised by Substantive Research.

“The cut in buy-side research budgets, the cost of managing all the reporting requirements associated with MiFID II, the difficulty of standing out in a crowded marketplace and the low volumes of trials of new research providers all make it harder for this group to thrive,” said the survey.

The buy side and sell side said asset owners will be the ultimate winners of MiFID II, and that high value interactions matter, but there was no consensus on any other issues.

“We are living through market formation, where the nature of research, its value, measurement and payment mechanisms are being reinvented in real time,” added the survey. “It would seem that more direct dialogue is needed and a more consensual understanding of what constitutes value.”

The survey found that between 25% and 40% of sales calls are charged for and there is a wide divergence of opinion between the sell side and buy side.

“70% of sell side stated sales calls should be paid for and nearly 80% of buy side saying they should not,”added the report. “A move to an industry standard approach seems distant.”

Preferred method of consuming research Source: Singlestack

Stuart Berwick, chief executive of Singletrack told Markets Media: “There is an opportunity to better connect the sellside and buyside with research that generates alpha. We have seen an increase in interest in portals which provide direct access in the last few years.”

The survey said buy-side firms showed a greater preference for research portals than the sell side and they do not seem to appreciate email distribution as much as the sell side and others believe.

Singletrack

Berwick, previously chief technology officer at JP Morgan, founded Singletrack in 2009 with Paul Dyson, who had launched an online systems consultancy. He told Markets Media that ten years ago they felt it was inevitable that financial services would move to the cloud due to the economics and flexibility.

Stuart Berwick, Singletrack

“We had a vision to make capital markets more data-driven,” added Berwick. “There had been little use of management information to optimise client relationships.”

He described Singletrack as a hub between buyside and sellside for both external and internal data which provides a record of all client interactions. For example, Singletrack Interaction Hub allows the buy side to collect accurate and relevant MiFID II data from the sell side.

Berwick sees a huge opportunity on the buy side.

“Many buy-side firms did the minimum to comply with MiFID II which may have involved spreadsheets and manual processes, he added. “They are now looking to industrialise and automate those processes.”

He continued that artificial intelligence and machine learning have huge applications in the analysis of data.

“For example, to automatically identify actionable opportunities from transcriptions of phone calls or Bloomberg chats,” he added.

Another example is that data can be analysed to identify the best investors to invite to a new issue roadshow.

“There has been a huge effort to increase the efficiency of trade execution and we want to transform the softer side of capital markets,” said Berwick. “There is an opportunity to generate value as execution has become commoditised.”

Markets Media Group was pleased to host the 2025 European Women in Finance Awards last night at Claridge’s in London.
#WomeninFinance #WIF #EuropeanFinance #FinanceCommunity

See the full list of winners here: https://www.marketsmedia.com/2025-european-women-in-finance-awards-the-winners/

3

We are excited to announce the finalists for the 2025 U.S. Women in Finance Awards! Congratulations to all!

Check out the full list here:


#WomeninFinance #WIF #financeindustry

Nominations are NOW OPEN for the 2026 Women in Finance LatAm Awards! Do you know a standout leader, innovator, or rising star? Nominate her today!

Learn more & submit your nomination:

#WomeninFinance #Finance #WIF

HSBC AI Markets harnesses natural language processing to meet market participants’ trading and hedging needs, from pre-trade analysis, to execution, to post-trade. Markets Media caught up with Tom Croft to learn more about the platform.

#AIMarkets

Load More

Related articles

  1. The board granted Fraser restricted stock units with a grant-date value of $25m and stock options.

  2. Outlook 2016: Alexander Lehmann, LSEG

    The transaction provides enhanced revenue share rights to SwapClear.

  3. The firm plans to increase its presence in the Middle East and is hiring private wealth advisors.

  4. The 60-story skyscraper at 270 Park Avenue can accommodate 10,000 employees.

  5. Versana allows tracking of an initial loan position through to its new refinanced facility.

We're Enhancing Your Experience with Smart Technology

We've updated our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy to introduce AI tools that will personalize your content, improve our market analysis, and deliver more relevant insights.These changes take effect on Aug 25, 2025.
Your data remains protected—we're simply using smart technology to serve you better. [Review Full Terms] | [Review Privacy Policy] Please review our updated Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy carefully. By continuing to use our services after Aug 25, 2025, you agree to these

Close the CTA