12.05.2013

Industry Groups Fight Cross-Border Rule

12.05.2013
Terry Flanagan

Industry groups are trying to stop rules that govern the cross-border aspects of OTC swaps trading.

The groups–Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association (Sifma), the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (Isda), and the Institute of International Bankers (IIB)—have filed a legal challenge to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) Cross-Border Rule, and to the cross-border aspects of related rules. The rule was published by the CFTC in July 2013.

The groups claim that the rule unlawfully circumvents the requirements of the Administrative Procedure Act and the Commodity Exchange Act by characterizing its regulations as “guidance.”

They also say that the CFTC failed to conduct any cost-benefit analysis, conducted a flawed rulemaking process, and imposed a series of rules that are contrary to the spirit and the letter of international cooperation and may harm global markets.

Policymakers have expressed concerns about the CFTC’s actions, including the November 14 Cross-Border and November 15 SEF advisories. The European Commission has stated it was “very surprised by the latest CFTC rules which seem to us to go against both the letter and spirit of the path forward agreement,” and that the rules “are another step away from the kind of inter-operable global system that we want to build.”

“Sifma and our members support responsible regulatory reform that will bring transparency and accountability to the derivatives markets,” said Sifma CEO Judd Gregg. The CFTC’s arbitrary and unilateral approach to cross-border regulation is backdoor rulemaking which has led to widespread market confusion and is creating significant impediments to the orderly functioning of financial markets worldwide.”

The lawsuit alleges that the CFTC failed to follow key requirements mandated by law with regard to development and issuance of the Cross-Border Rule. The Associations believe that the Cross-Border Rule violates existing agreements between global policymakers, and works against the G20 Commitment to “implement global standards consistently in a way that ensures a level playing field and avoids fragmentation of markets.”

The Cross-Border Rule, they say, further creates significant financial, legal and administrative burdens on market participants that could harm liquidity and the ability of end-users to manage their risks.

As a result of the confusing process around the development of the Cross-Border Rule and the CFTC’s lack of coordination with the SEC or foreign regulatory bodies, non-U.S. counterparties have become increasingly reluctant to transact with U.S. based dealers or even with non-U.S. dealers that have U.S. personnel involved in the transaction.

“The CFTC’s Cross-Border Rule, however, is a step backward in our mutual efforts to develop a robust, consistent and global framework for OTC derivatives regulation that reduces systemic risk,” said Isda chairman Stephen O’Connor. “It harms the financial system and market participants and adversely impacts the ability of end-users to hedge their business and financial risks.”

The Cross-Border Rule could undermine the global commitment to coordination and lead to such conflicts in several ways, the groups claim. For example, a firm could be required to execute the same trade on two different platforms and to clear the same transaction on two different clearinghouses. Transactions could be required to be reported in two jurisdictions.

The Cross-Border Rule could further create significant administrative, legal and financial costs for market participants with no apparent benefits. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has acknowledged the importance of coordination in its substituted compliance approach to cross-border swaps rulemaking for securities-based swaps, the groups noted, while CFTC relief provided thus far is inadequate in scope and/or time limited, leaving critical uncertainties pending.

Pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, endowments and other institutional asset owners are sitting on vast troves of data -- but extracting value from that data is more challenging than ever.

#AssetOwners #DataQuality

Technology costs in asset management have grown disproportionately, but McKinsey research finds the increased spending hasn’t consistently translated into higher productivity.
#AI #Fiance

We're in the FINAL WEEK for the European Women in Finance Awards nominations – don't miss your chance to spotlight the incredible women driving change in finance!
#WomenInFinance #FinanceAwards #FinanceCommunity #EuropeanFinance @WomeninFinanceM

ICYMI: @marketsmedia sat down with EDXM CEO Tony Acuña-Rohter to discuss the launch of EDXM International’s perpetual futures platform in Singapore and what it means for institutional crypto trading.
Read the full interview: https://bit.ly/45xRUWh

Load More

Related articles

  1. This makes a traditionally hard-to-access market available to crypto-native investors and institutions.

  2. UK Launches Asset Management Review

    They will create 1,800 jobs across London, Edinburgh, Belfast and Manchester.

  3. From The Markets

    U.S. ETF Assets Reach Record

    Year-to-date net inflows of $798.77bn are an all-time high.

  4. The ETF gives exposure to euro sovereigns through a climate transition-focused investment strategy.

  5. Pool tokens allow a range of already tokenised assets to be put together into a new token.

We're Enhancing Your Experience with Smart Technology

We've updated our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy to introduce AI tools that will personalize your content, improve our market analysis, and deliver more relevant insights.These changes take effect on Aug 25, 2025.
Your data remains protected—we're simply using smart technology to serve you better. [Review Full Terms] | [Review Privacy Policy] By continuing to use our services after Aug 25, 2025, you agree to these updates.

Close the CTA